Teenage girl avoids assault conviction in school bullying case
File image
A teenage girl charged with assault causing harm at school when she was 14 avoided a conviction in court, after a “positive” probation report recommended a referral to the Juvenile Liaison Officer (JLO).
Now aged 17, the girl was aged 14 at the time of what was described in court as “an ongoing bullying situation” in school. The victim has since left the school.
Appearing at Naas District Court this month, the defendant confirmed she had pleaded guilty at a previous hearing to a lesser charge of section 2 assault, reduced from one of assault causing harm, which was accepted by the State.
Sergeant Ruth Coleman explained: “This was between two 14-year-old girls at (a named school in Co Kildare) during an ongoing bullying situation.”
The sergeant said the situation “came to a head” on 18 September 2024, when the defendant struck the other girl on the head.
She added: “It was a closed fist on the left-hand side of the face. The injured party has refused to make a victim impact statement. She has since left the school and is in counselling.”
Solicitor David Powderley told Judge Desmond Zaidan that there was a “very positive” Extern report on the defendant.
Extern is a community organisation started over 50 years ago, now working across Ireland supporting young people on issues of crime, consequences and rehabilitation.
The solicitor told the judge: “So, I would plead with you not to give a custodial sentence. She has attended with her father on every occasion and her principal has also attended on her behalf before.
“The probation report is also positive and Mr Pickles (probation officer) has asked to refer this to the JLO.”
Judge Zaidan commented: “Totally flying off the handle is not the way to deal with something like this.”
“Have you learned?” he asked the girl.
Quietly, and with head down, she said: “Yes.”
The judge applied the Probation Act, with no conviction recorded. The teenager cannot be identified due to her age, which also precludes naming the school.
